Your campaign stats are hiding your results
When a client opens their campaign report, the numbers they see make the campaign look weaker than it is. Last week, a client's campaign cards showed a 0% SMS open rate and a 0.0 rating, while four new 5-star Google reviews had arrived, each within two minutes of a contact being redirected from the campaign. Clients judge the product, and our agency, on that screen.
What happens today
Reviews left on Google are never counted: once the contact leaves for the review site, the platform cannot see the review, so the campaign rating stays at 0.0. I matched them by hand: contact redirected at 19:18:04, Google review published at 19:18:53, same store. Four out of four matched within two minutes.
SMS open rate shows 0%. SMS opens cannot be tracked at all, but "0%" reads as "nobody opened it".
Email opens are undercounted. Three emails were clicked and still counted as not opened (image blocking, privacy proxies). Clicks are reliable; opens are not.
Proposal
Say "not tracked" instead of 0% for SMS opens, and flag email opens as an estimate (or count a click as an open, so clicked > opened never happens).
Likely reviews: after a redirect, if a new review appears on that same source and location within a short window (for example 10 minutes), count it as a "likely review from this campaign" and link the two. This uses time only, not names, so usernames do not break it. Show it as a separate line, so it never claims more than the data supports.
Campaign period view: reviews received on each location while the campaign runs, next to the same period before. It is the number a business owner actually cares about.
Log in to comment and vote
Comments1
Linked to Review attempted → Actual Review Made
Seb Gardies
Nov 21
Screenshots from a real client account (names blurred): the campaign cards the client sees, then one contact’s activity.