Skip to main content

One brand, two organizations: only one can use its domain

When a client has two Google Business Profiles, I set them up as two organizations. Only the first one can send review requests from the brand's own email domain. The second gets "Could not create a new sender: Domain with same name already exists" and keeps sending from the platform's default address. Its customers receive a request signed with the brand's name but sent from an unrelated address: more spam folder, and it looks like phishing.

What happens today

  1. Organization A (client X): Settings › Email settings › Sender domain, enter brand.com, Save. The domain is created and the DNS records are shown.

  2. Organization B (same client, same brand, its own location and Google profile): same page, enter brand.com, Save.

  3. Error: "Could not create a new sender: Domain with same name already exists". There is no way to link the existing domain, so organization B stays on the default sender.

The error looks like it comes from the email provider (Brevo here), which already holds brand.com, authenticated for organization A in the same agency account.

The same limit shows up inside one organization: two brands sharing an organization can't each have their own domain, since an organization takes one sender domain.

Proposal

  1. If the domain already exists in the agency's provider account, let another organization of the same client use it (link instead of create), with its verification status.

  2. Better: manage sender domains at the client level, and let each organization pick its domain.

  3. At least, replace the raw error with a clear message ("This domain is already used by organization A") and what to do next.

Related request from 2024, same need across locations: https://roadmap.embedmyreviews.com/en/p/e-mail-settings

Log in to comment and vote

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts.